22nd November 2022
One of my followers from the Isle of Man on my Website showed me the following reply he received upon emailing that the Isle of Man’s Chief Minister (the equivalent of the UK’s Prime Minister)- about Public funding to set up a bespoke Isle of Man TV service:
Thank you for your email.
We are always looking to improve the service that we receive from the BBC. We have in the past sought more coverage from the BBC and believe that this has been delivered to some degree via improved regional website and also via dedicated reporting.
A TV channel for the Isle of Man is not a current priority for this Government. You will be aware of course that we do pay a substantial subvention (£995k) to Manx Radio to maintain the services of a national broadcaster.
Chief Minister, Hon. Alfred Cannan, MHK
The Isle of Man has a population of just over 86,000 according to the most recent figures available (details here: https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/isle-of-man-population/), and GDP per capita (from 2019, the latest data) is as high as $83,920 (details here: https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/IMN/isle-of-man/gni-per-capita). In Sterling, assuming average exchange rate of £1.00 being $1.28 in 2019 that would be £65,562. Even allowing for recession and Inflation cutting that by 10% in 2022 that’s still per-capita income of £59,006 (the Isle of Man Pound is pegged to the British Pound): For the Isle of Man as a whole, this means that the Isle of Man is one of the wealthiest countries in the world, though most of the population are much poorer than this.
Now, a new Isle of Man TV-service would cost £10 million a year at a push, which sounds a lot of money but that is less than £120 a year per capita, or just slightly over 0.2% of GDP. Most folk living on the Isle of Man do not earn anything like £59,000 a year, but there is a minority of extremely wealthy individuals who could be required to pay another £5,000 in tax as one- off to help set up the new Isle of Man TV- service to raise a block grant of £50,000,000. If the Manx Government did not want to tap the wealthy -for fear of capital flight- they could borrow this money- which works out at just 1% of GDP for one year only. Since the Isle of Man has very low government debt it could afford it as a one- off (refer to article here: https://www.gov.im/media/1373037/moodys-isle-of-man-credit-opinion-report-may-2021.pdf).
Alternatively, a half-way house of tapping the wealthy for just £2,500 and raising 0.5% in debt (both as a one-off) is scarcely going to cause an exodus of wealth from the Isle of Man. The Manx government borrowed £400 million to invest in infrastructure projects in 2021 (i.e. eight times as much as to set up and run a Manx TV service for five years), so the excuse that they can’t borrow the money- in order to keep debt low- does not wash (details here of the Manx Government borrowing money: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-isle-of-man-58543924).
This £50,000,000 would make the new Manx TV- service self-funding for five years: Legislation could be passed to ensure that the money was only used for Manx-only News, Sport and Documentaries and to provide legal protections to ensure a future Government could not take the money away if the news- service broadcast anything critical of the Manx Government. Legislation could also be passed to stop the new Manx TV service wasting the money and not providing a bespoke Manx news- service. In addition, the Manx TV service should be allowed to have some subscription charge (capped at £40 per household) and allowed some advertising slots (only between programmes), and business- sponsoring of programming to raise the money needed to make the new Isle of Man TV- service funding over the longer-term. The Isle of Man Government would still have very low debt levels, a fraction of what the UK has compared to GDP
Other small island countries in the North Atlantic, like the Faroe Islands, have their own national TV service in spite of the country being poorer with bow lower population and less gross national income per head of population. Details about the Faroe Islands own TV News- service are here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kringvarp_F%C3%B8roya, and it provides news- reports in English as well as in Faroese. According to the latest statistics the population of the Faroe Islands was just over 49,000 in 2022 (https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/faeroe-islands-population/).
Returning, therefore to the reply that my follower on this Website received from The Chief Minister, Hon. Alfred Cannan, MHK it indicates that the Manx Government, the Government of one of the richest small nations in the World in terms of GDP is happy for viewers to get a scant 5% of coverage off the BBC “local” news broadcast to the Isle of Man, ditto from ITV1 Granada Reports. The Manx Government is OK about the Isle of Man being part of a huge BBC Super-Region- stretching to the North Sea Coast of East Yorkshire and Lincolnshire for the “Local slant” (yes, that’s how the BBC describe it!) -on national issues in a documentary series called We Are England. Skegness, on the Lincolnshire coast. It is 283 miles from Ramsey, in the north of the Isle of Man- to Skegness, on the Lincolnshire coast by road and ferry- a trip that would take over eight hours in good weather! Yet both Ramsey and Skegness have been put in the same BBC1 Super-Region for the We Are England documentaries!!
Why, also should Manx viewers be subject to a documentary called We Are England– as well as being told it’s local anyway? The Isle of Man is another country, albeit a Crown Dependency of the UK. But it’s not England! Yet, the Manx government seems to be okay with the Manx citizens under it’s care being (effectively) sidelined and ignored by programming from another country because it has “other priorities”! Folk living on the Isle of Man need to wise up, they should be up in arms at this, especially when the governments of much poorer small nations make the effort to ensure their country has a national news- service that serves their people!
If you live on the Isle of Man I would not advise just sending an e-mail to the Chief Minister, Hon. Alfred Cannan, MHK: This is shocking given the Chief Minister’s reply to a Manx voter! That £995,000 spent subsidising radio would be better put towards setting up a Manx TV service that has pictures and visial footage and maps of places, which you cannot get from radio. Write a letter, marked FAO Chief Minister, The Hon. Alfred Cannan, MHK and affixed URGENT. Make it very clear that you consider the Zero Public funding for setting up a Manx-only TV service to be an affront to Manx citizens (who democratically elected his government)- when they are forced to watch BBC1/ ITV1 “local news” about Manchester/ Cheshire up to 150 miles away by road, and BBC “local” documentaries- with the title of another country- and about places up to 283 miles away- should Manx viewers want to watch local news and documentaries! In fact, do not consider writing such a letter alone, get your family and friends to write to Hon. Alfred Cannan, MHK too. Point out that you know that the uber-rich are taxed lightly and that Government debt is low- that the Government could find the money to set up a Manx TV- service if there was the will to do so!
It does beg the question as to why the Isle of Man government does not seem to want a bespoke Manx TV-service providing Manx-only news and documentaries: After all, they could afford it to raise the funds to get it going and it would benefit their electorate greatly, for it is certain that viewers cannot be happy one iota with the output they get from BBC1 North West Tonight and ITV1 Granada Reports, let alone a “Local” documentary series called We Are England talking about Hull or Lincolnshire!! One might wonder if the real reason is that Hon. Members of the House of Keys fear the greater scrutiny that they would undoubtedly get if there was a bespoke, independent Manx TV service providing news and documentaries about the Isle of Man?
To write to the Chief Minister, the Hon. Alfred Cannan MHK and send a letter by post the details are:
Hon. Alfred Cannan, MHK
Office of the Chief Minister
In the meantime, this Website which campaigns for better Regional TV for the Isle of Man, as well as for Lancashire and South Cumbria in North West England, will continue to draw attention to what viewers on the Isle of Man get in terms of their national (as well as local) broadcast representation, or rather what they don’t get! National and TV News- reporting about happenings which is relevant to viewers- it is a Public service, just as Libraries and bin-collections are. People are not represented, their interests are not championed and they cannot make informed choices if they don’t have good-quality local news-coverage. Folk living on the Isle of Man should be outside the House of Keys with their banners: It is bad that the Manx Government cannot use any of that small country’s not-insigificant financial-resources to enable people there to get news about their own country! Of course, £995,000 spent on radio is better than nothing but it would be better put to setting up a Manx TV service- maybe local businesses and a cheap subscription can fund the rest.
Finally, if you live on the Isle of Man who may or may not be aware of You Tube based Isle of Man TV: Whilst not a TV-service in the conventional sense, you can watch it on the Internet from this website address https://www.youtube.com/c/IsleofManTV. That does, at least, you can get some form of bespoke Manx news-coverage though not through relaxing in front of the TV. And folk without a computer with Internet would not be able to watch it anyway! However, if you can get the You Tube- based Isle of Man TV you can boycott BBC1 North West Tonight, ITV1 Granada Reports and, above all, that BBC1 “Local” TV documentary series called We Are England. If you plan to do that, do drop the North West England Regional TV News-services a line at firstname.lastname@example.org and, for BBC1 North West Tonight, email email@example.com. Maybe, just maybe, that will lead to either BBC1 North West Tonight or ITV1 Granada Reports providing an opt-out in their programming for the Isle of Man, because what they don’t want is to lose viewers.